A Reason for Pain?

Quest for Teachers

As your students grapple with understanding why Christians suffer pain, it might be interest­ing to quote the noted author C. S. Lewis, who wrote, "God whispers in our pleasures, but shouts in our pain." Understanding that God has a purpose in what He allows us to go through can help your students to keep an opti­mistic outlook of faith when the waves of trouble roll in.

God wants us to be prepared for the pain­filled issues that will come into our lives, and that is the point you will want to develop with your group. The assurance that God is deeply involved and offers personal assistance and infinite understanding when we face pain is an indescribable help. Draw your students' atten­tion to the many times the word "comfort" ap­pears in the 2 Corinthians text. That word comes from the Greek terms para, meaning "beside, alongside," and kaleo, "to call." Together they mean, "called alongside." No matter what our need, God will be alongside to share our pain.


The students will be able to explain how God would have the Christian react to suffering, and to relate some of the ways that good can come of the suffering in our lives.

Key Texts

Job 23:14; Psalms 34:19; 119:71; Proverbs 3:11,12; Isaiah 43:2; 48:10; 53:4; Mark 14:36; John 15:2; 16:33; Romans 5:3,4; 8:17,28; 2 Corinthians 1:3,4,9,11; 12:10; Hebrews 4:14-16; 10:25; James 4:7; 1 Peter 4:12

Questions and Suggested Responses

Question 1 - When we hear the words "pain" or "suffering," we
might associate them with serious illness, injury, or other physical trauma. Certainly that is often the type of pain a person faces, but the scope of circumstances that bring suf­fering into our lives goes far beyond that. In your own words, define pain, and give several examples of situations that could cause it.

Response 1 - The examples given should help your group conclude that pain is anything that brings grief or suffering. It might be physical trauma, but a broad range of other pain-causing situations could also come our way: a wayward child, a broken friendship, a disagreement, a loss by death, a backslidden brother, or a personal failure. It might be interesting to note your students' responses on a dry erase board, dividing the examples given into three categories: physical pain, emotional pain, and spiritual pain. Then help your group to analyze the three categories. How are they alike? How are they different? How do we react to each of them? How might they change our lives? The point is to help your group understand that while we might feel alone in our suffering, there are others around us who are hurting too, although perhaps for very different reasons.

Question 2 - Some people find it difficult to accept the fact that a loving, omnipotent God allows pain and trouble to come
into the lives of His children, but an honest examination of the Scriptures reveals this to be true. Yes, Jesus said, "In the world ye shall have tribulation:" but remember that He added, "be of good cheer; I have overcome the world." Through our pain we can experience God's process of refin­ing the precious metal of Christian character. Romans 5:3,4 says that "tribulation worketh patience; and patience, expe­rience; and experience, hope." The "pruning" that God does in the life of a Christian is vastly different from punishment. Elaborate on the dif­ference.

Response 2 - Class discussion should bring out that pruning is not done to inflict pain, but to remove certain parts of a plant that hinder its productivity. When God "prunes" us, He has an end result in view, and He determines what will best accomplish this in our lives. God's "punish­ment," on the other hand, is reserved for "the day of judgment" (2 Peter 2:9). That judgment will be punishment for evildoers (1 Peter 2:14) and not for the Christians. God does not punish His children-He corrects them.

Question 3 - In our minds, we need to settle the fact that what we face isn't a random occurrence without purpose or design. As Christians, God allows affliction to come upon us only for good.Job said of God, "He performeth the thing that is appointed for me" Job 23:14). Paul wrote, "All things work together for good to them that love God" (Romans 8:28). Acknowledging that God has allowed our trial will make it easier to bear. When we recognize that we are in this place by His will, we find rest in our spirit. We have chosen to trust in the overruling goodness, providence, and sover­eignty of God, and He will not fail us.
We certainly don't want any affliction we go through to be wasted time. In the first chapter of 2 Corinthians, Paul elaborates on three reasons for affliction. First, read verses 4, 9, and 11 of that chapter, and note what God would want each of us to do with what we have learned. Then, look up the following Scriptures. Beside each one, note something positive we might learn while going through an affliction.

Response 3 - Paul lets us know, in the first chapter of 2 Corinthians, that we might go through afflictions "that we may be able to com­fort" (verse 4), "that we should not trust in our­selves, but in God" (verse 9), "that ... thanks may be given" (verse 11). Allow your class to summa­rize the other verses listed. Those verses let us know that possible reasons for affliction and positive things learned through affliction are:

Psalm 34:19 - to learn God's power to de­liver His children out of affliction

Psalm 119:71 - to learn God's statutes (His Word)

Proverbs 3:11,12 - to learn that correction and discipline show the depth of God's love for His children

Isaiah 43:2 - an awareness of God's pres­ence in every situation

Isaiah 48:10 - to learn the value of refine­ment

John 15:2 - to learn that "pruning" will help us to bear spiritual fruit

Romans 8:17 - to give us the opportunity to be glorified with Him

2 Corinthians 12:10 - to discover what Christ can do for us in our times of weakness, because though we are weak, we can be strong in Christ

Question 4 - Give a brief summary of the affliction of Job, and comment upon some of the "fruit" that resulted from his affliction.

Response 4 - We know that Job's character was impeccable. God himself said of Job, "There is none like him in the earth, a perfect and an up­right man, one that feareth God, and escheweth evil" (Job 1:8). Job certainly would not be chas­tened for this manner of living-sin was not the reason for his bankrupt and broken condition. However, God has a purpose for everything He allows to come into the lives of His children. As Christians, we don't live for ourselves, but for God (Romans 14:8), and our reaction to situa­tions that come our way might impact the lives of others. If we can grasp this truth, then we can begin to understand why God allowed Job to be tempted and tried in such an extreme way. Job is an example to us of how God's love and mercy is so great that anyone who is completely surren­dered to God can accept whatever God allows to come his way-even though he can see no good reason for it. Consider also the beautiful verses of encouragement found in the Book of Job that have influenced believers for thousands of years. Help your group to understand that, whatever God's intention is in our pain, we can trust Him.

Question 5 - Sometimes God reaches down and changes circumstances supernaturally. Sometimes He does not. What de­termines whether God ,vill perform a miracle? Is it all right to ask for one? Should we try to bolster our faith to reach out and claim the answer we desire? These questions may haunt the one who is hurting and sees no natural solution to his problem. How would you respond to someone who came to you with these questions? See Mark 14:36.

Response 5 - Class discussion should bring out that faith is not a means of coercing God into doing something He never intended. Whether or not He will perform a miracle is in His hands. Jesus' prayer in Gethsemane helps us to under­stand that with God all things are possible, and if we include "God's will" in our prayer of faith, we can trust that the things which happen in our lives are allowed by Him. However, we certainly may pray for a miracle. Any heart's cry that reaches out to the Almighty for a touch from His hand can be expressed by a child of God, but the basis for our prayer should be, "Thy will be done." We should not come to God demanding or thinking to earn a self-shaped answer to our re­quest by our great faith. There are times when disease, trials, or heartaches come and are not taken away, but they don't have to defeat us. If our trust is in God, then we will offer our praise in whatever answer He sends, because we have confidence that He knows what is best for us.

Question 6 - God's Word lets us know that it is not strange or un­usual for Christians to go through trials. (See I Peter 4:12.)
We know that God is committed to making something beautiful, valuable, and eternally lasting of our lives, and for this reason He allows the "fiery trial" to come our way. How can we cooperate with God in this refining process? Give Scriptures to support your answers.

Response 6 - Your group should see that our initial step of cooperation in the refining process must be a total submission to God's will-to pray as Jesus did, "Not my will, but thine be done" (Luke 22:42). James 5:10,11 brings out that we are to have patience and endurance, considering the example of others who have gone through hard places. In 1 Peter 4:13,14, we find that we are to accept suffering with joy. Reading of Job's trial (Job 1:22) helps us see the wisdom of not charging God foolishly when we are afflicted. We are admonished in 1 Thessalonians 5:18 to give thanks in everything, and this would in­clude during times of suffering. We are to look to God for strength and grace to overcome (Philippians 4:13; 2 Corinthians 12:9).

Question 7 - The devil never hesitates to attack when we are down. He watches for just such a time, knowing that our defenses may be weakened. When suffering comes into the lives of God's children, Satan is quick to follow with accusations and fears—insinuating that God doesn't really care about us. If we give in to complaining, self-pity, or bitterness, he has us exactly where he wants us. James 4:7 and Hebrews 10:25 give us some ways to deal effectively with the doubts, accu­sations, and fears that so often accompany suffering. Give other Scriptures that will comfort us when we are hurting.

Response 7 - James 4:7 tells us that if we re­sist the devil, he will flee from us. Bring out the fact that Satan is the accuser of the brethren (Revelation 12:10) and that he is a liar. Remind­ing ourselves of past victories over his insinua­tions can be a powerful weapon. We can praise God and plead the Blood of Jesus against the enemy's attack. Your students might also sug­gest discussing the problem with a minister or Christian friend. Attending church whenever possible is another effective way of withstanding Satan's attempts, for we find strength and en­couragement in fellowship with other believers (Hebrews 10:25).

Question 8 - In 2 Corinthians 1:3, we find a beautiful description of God—one that offers special meaning to us in the time of trial. This Scripture refers to Him as "the Father of mercies, and the God of all comfort." The next verse says He com­forts us in all our tribulation. What a wonderful message of hope in our dark hour! In Isaiah 53:4, we read, "Surely he hath borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows." Notice that this verse has no limits. It doesn't say He has borne some of our griefs and carried part of our sorrows. Our suffering is always shared by Christ. Read Hebrews 4:14-16. Describe the office of Christ, as depicted in this passage, and explain how He ministers to us in our time of need.

Response 8 - The passage in Hebrews tells us Jesus is our High Priest. He was made like us in every way, yet without sin, so He is able to sym­pathize with our weaknesses and is touched by the feeling of our infirmities. At the tomb of Lazarus, Jesus felt the combined weight of His grief and that of those around Him, and He wept. We can confidently approach the Throne of Grace with our deepest feelings of grief, frus­tration, doubt, suffering, and heartache. There we will "find grace to help in time of need."